how did morgan spurlock demonstrate ethos in super size me

Lussy04

2 min read

·

24-01-2025

1

0

Share

Morgan Spurlock's 2004 documentary, Super Size Me, isn't just a shocking exposé on the fast-food industry; it's a masterclass in establishing ethos, the rhetorical appeal based on credibility and trustworthiness. Spurlock cleverly crafts his argument by demonstrating his own commitment to the experiment, highlighting his expertise (or lack thereof), and ultimately, revealing his vulnerability. This multifaceted approach solidifies his credibility and persuades the audience to accept his findings.

The Power of Self-Experimentation: Putting Himself on the Line

The most striking aspect of Spurlock's ethos building is his willingness to undergo the experiment himself. He doesn't just report on the dangers of McDonald's; he becomes the living, breathing example. This self-imposed challenge immediately establishes his investment in the film's message. He's not detachedly observing; he's actively participating, sharing his physical and emotional journey with the audience. This vulnerability makes him relatable and fosters trust. We see the direct consequences of his actions, making the documentary's claims more impactful.

Physical and Emotional Transparency

Spurlock doesn't shy away from documenting the negative physical and emotional changes he experiences. We witness his weight gain, his mood swings, his declining health. This honesty is crucial in building his ethos. It shows he's not afraid to present the full picture, including the less flattering aspects of the experiment. This transparency helps disarm potential criticisms and strengthens his credibility.

Highlighting Limitations and Expertise (or Lack Thereof)

Interestingly, Spurlock also builds ethos by acknowledging his limitations. He's not a doctor or a nutritionist; he's a filmmaker conducting a social experiment. This self-awareness avoids the pitfalls of appearing overly authoritative. He openly admits his lack of scientific expertise, inviting the audience to interpret the results alongside him. This transparency, rather than weakening his argument, strengthens it. He's not claiming to have all the answers but is presenting compelling evidence based on his experience.

Consulting Experts: A Balanced Approach

While Spurlock emphasizes his own personal journey, he also incorporates interviews with medical professionals and nutritionists. Their expert opinions corroborate his findings, adding scientific backing to his largely experiential study. This is a smart strategy for bolstering his credibility. It shows he acknowledges the need for expert input and is not solely relying on his personal experience.

A Call to Action: Beyond Personal Experience

The film's conclusion doesn't just present the data; it calls for a broader societal change. Spurlock's commitment to his experiment, his acknowledgement of limitations, and the support he gathers from experts all contribute to his persuasiveness. By sharing his personal experience and highlighting the need for informed choices, he empowers the audience to make changes in their own lives.

Conclusion: Ethos as a Foundation

In Super Size Me, Morgan Spurlock masterfully builds his ethos not through detached objectivity, but through honest self-experimentation, transparency, and the strategic inclusion of expert opinions. He presents himself as a relatable figure embarking on a crucial journey, building a foundation of trust that lends significant weight to his documentary's ultimately compelling and impactful message. The power of his message lies precisely in this carefully constructed credibility.