is everyone in the spider society an idiot

2 min read 25-01-2025

is everyone in the spider society an idiot

The jaw-dropping animation and exhilarating action of Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse captivated audiences. But amidst the dazzling visuals and multiverse mayhem, a question lingered for many: are all the Spider-People in the Spider-Society… well, a little unhinged? This isn't about Miles Morales's competence; it's about the supporting cast and their questionable decisions. Let's dive into the chaotic brilliance and frustrating flaws of the Spider-Society.

The Problem with the Council

The Spider-Society's leadership, the council, is presented as experienced and wise. They claim to act for the greater good, protecting the multiverse from threats. Yet, their actions often raise more questions than they answer. Their decisions frequently prioritize arcane rules and tradition over common sense. This creates significant friction with Miles and challenges the very notion of their competence. Are they truly guiding the multiverse, or just clinging to outdated ways?

Their Biggest Mistakes:

Ignoring Warnings: The council consistently dismisses Miles's concerns about the Spot, underestimating the threat he poses. Their arrogance blinds them to clear danger signals.
Rigid Rules: Their adherence to a strict code undermines their ability to adapt to new situations. The inflexible rules frequently hinder effective problem-solving, putting the multiverse at risk.
Poor Communication: The council struggles to effectively communicate its plans and reasoning to its members. This leads to confusion and distrust, exacerbating existing problems.

Questionable Choices from Other Spider-People

The film showcases numerous Spider-People, each with their own unique skills and experiences. While some demonstrate genuine heroism, others make perplexing choices. Are these choices simply character flaws, or evidence of a systemic problem within the Society itself?

Examples of questionable judgment:

Spider-Woman (Gwen Stacy): While Gwen is generally competent and resourceful, her emotional turmoil often clouds her judgment. Her impulsive actions, driven by grief and guilt, put others at risk.
Spider-Man 2099 (Miguel O'Hara): Miguel, the supposed leader, is particularly rigid in his adherence to the rules. His belief in his own infallibility blinds him to alternative solutions and leads to his severe misjudgment of Miles.

Is it Intentional? The Art of Chaos

The seemingly irrational behavior of the Spider-Society isn't necessarily a flaw in the writing. The film excels at portraying the complexities of heroism, showcasing that even the most experienced heroes make mistakes. This isn't about everyone being an idiot; it's about highlighting the vulnerabilities and flaws inherent in even the most seemingly infallible protectors of the multiverse. The chaos, then, is deliberate, creating compelling conflict and underscoring the thematic complexities of the film.

The Bigger Picture: A Necessary Dysfunction?

The Spider-Society's dysfunction may be essential to the narrative. Their flaws challenge Miles, forcing him to question their authority and ultimately discover his own path as a hero. The film's success lies in presenting the complexities of these characters, acknowledging that even the best of intentions can lead to disastrous outcomes.

Ultimately, Across the Spider-Verse doesn't suggest everyone in the Spider-Society is an idiot. Rather, it presents a multifaceted, flawed group of heroes striving to protect the multiverse, highlighting the internal conflicts and challenges inherent in such a vast and complex organization. The imperfections of the Spider-Society aren't necessarily a sign of incompetence; they are a key component in the overall narrative's compelling complexities.

What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments below! Did the Spider-Society's actions drive you crazy, or did you find their flaws to be a strength of the film?